Volumetric vs. Gravimetric Feeding?
by Joseph Marinelli
Printer
friendly PDF
There are many types of feeders available to handle
bulk solids and they can be divided into two categories: volumetric and gravimetric. A
volumetric feeder discharges a volume of material as a function of time while a
gravimetric feeder weighs material.
Volumetric feeders
Volumetric feeding is adequate for many solids feeding applications.
Feed accuracy in the range of 2-5% can be achieved with most volumetric designs.
Volumetric feeding can, however become inaccurate if the bulk
density of the solid that is being handled varies. The feeder cannot recognize a density
change because it simply discharges a certain volume per unit time.
Examples of
volumetric type feeders are: screws, belts, rotary valves, louvered type, and vibratory.
Gravimetric feeders
A gravimetric feeder relies on weighing the material to achieve a
required discharge rate or batch weight. This approach should be used when:
- Accuracy of less than 5% is required
- The material's bulk density varies
- A record the weight of material used for a particular process.
Feed accuracy of 0.25% is sometimes obtainable with a properly
designed gravimetric feed system. A disadvantage of a feeder that weighs material is that
it is usually more expensive than a volumetric device.
There are basically two ways to feed gravimetrically, continuous and
batch. A continuous gravimetric system controls the weight/unit time such as lbs./hr
or kg/hr. A batch system controls simply the weight of material such as 50 lbs. of
material to a mixer. Examples of gravimetric feeders are: weigh-belts, loss-in-weight
systems, and gain-in-weight systems.
In subsequent articles, we will discuss each type of volumetric and
gravimetric feed system in more detail.
Help others by posting your comments, suggestions and
experiences with bulk solids feeding or any other materials handling concerns you may have
on our On-Line Help Forum. For
past Ask Joe ! Articles, visit the Ask Joe! Archived Articles.
Guest articles for the Ask Joe! Column are always welcome,
for more information please contact Joe Marinelli directly at his email address:
joe@solidshandlingtech.com.
|